Buried Sin

Jared DeWhite, Dwayne Oswald, and Eugene dig up a mystery when they uncover a long-lost box, which contains the story of a forgotten crime.


Chris: Hi, this is Chris. Welcome to Adventures in Odyssey.
Eugene Meltsner: Eugene Melzner here, inviting you to join today's assemblage of characters and myself for an extended period of discovery, imagination, and exhilaration. Uh, excitement, that is. Welcome to Adventures in Odyssey.
Chris: It looks like a box.
Dwayne Oswald: Whoa.
Chris: I'll bet it's some kind of secret treasure.
Eugene Meltsner: Odyssey citizen dies from mystery gunshot.
Chris: I think it came from over there, near the general store.
Eugene Meltsner: No, it didn't.
Chris: Wait a second, this can't be.
Dwayne Oswald: Good heavens.
Chris: Don't you see? It's like a mission from God. Seasonal felicitations. Hi, Gene.
Eugene Meltsner: Oh, greetings and salutations, Jared, Dwayne.
Dwayne Oswald: We saw you out here digging and thought we'd see what you were doing.
Eugene Meltsner: Ah, I'm conducting a horticultural experiment. Would you care to assist?
Chris: Uh, sure, but what's a horticultural, and why are you going to experiment on it?
Eugene Meltsner: Yes, allow me to show you. Take the shovel, please. Now, continue to dig where I've been digging, right there.
Chris: All right.
Eugene Meltsner: A little to the left, please. Thank you.
Chris: All right. What are we supposed to be observing here, Eugene, besides my blisters?
Eugene Meltsner: We are observing the birth of a garden in the tradition of the Austrian monk Gregor Mendel, the great genetic pioneer.
Dwayne Oswald: Oh.
Eugene Meltsner: Whilst pursuing Mendel's manifold manuscripts, I was intrigued by his genetic study of garden peas.
Chris: Wait, wait a second. We're doing all this work for peas?
Eugene Meltsner: Precisely. You will soon enjoy the fruits of your labor.
Dwayne Oswald: Isn't that more like the vegetables of your labor?
Eugene Meltsner: Ahem.
Chris: Hmm.
Dwayne Oswald: What was that?
Chris: I don't know, a rock or something.
Dwayne Oswald: Rocks don't go cathunk.
Eugene Meltsner: I wonder.
Chris: It's something wooden. It looks like a box.
Eugene Meltsner: Whoa!
Chris: I'll bet it's some kind of secret treasure.
Eugene Meltsner: Uh, highly unlikely, and yet, uh, Jared, you take that side and we'll try to extract the object.
Chris: All right.
Eugene Meltsner: Just a little more.
Chris: All right, I got it.
Eugene Meltsner: Here we... Wow! Extraordinary.
Chris: What is it?
Eugene Meltsner: It appears to be some sort of containment device.
Chris: Yeah, a box, like I said. You gonna open it?
Eugene Meltsner: If I'm able. What is it? Curious.
Chris: Curious? Let me see. A hat, a piece of newspaper, something wrapped up. It's a bunch of old stuff, no treasure.
Eugene Meltsner: Yes, but why would someone go to all the trouble of burying these items?
Chris: Ran out of room in the garbage can?
Eugene Meltsner: Hmm, see, this newspaper article is from, 1921, so one might assume that this box was buried around that time. This is quite a mystery.
Chris: It is.
Dwayne Oswald: So, what are you going to do with it, Eugene?
Eugene Meltsner: I believe I shall take it to someone well versed in items of this vintage.
Chris: Meaning what?
Eugene Meltsner: I shall take them to Mr. Jack Allen at J and J's Antiques. Would you care to join me since you're partners in this find?
Dwayne Oswald: Well, sure. After all, it is a mystery.
Eugene Meltsner: Indeed, a mystery.
Jack Allen: So this was buried behind Wit's End.
Eugene Meltsner: You'll notice a yellowed newspaper article inside dated 1921, along with other artifacts presumably from that period.
Jack Allen: It's an interesting collection. Did you notice the headline on the article?
Eugene Meltsner: Indeed. Odyssey citizen dies from mystery gunshot.
Chris: Hey, you didn't tell us there was a murder, Eugene.
Eugene Meltsner: Oh, did I neglect to mention it?
Dwayne Oswald: But why would somebody save that?
Jack Allen: Mm, good question. Let's see, what else is... Ah, a fedora.
Chris: Mr. Allen, look, there's an envelope stuck inside the hat fedora thing.
Dwayne Oswald: Hmm.
Chris: A secret note. Read it, Mr. Allen.
Dwayne Oswald: Let's see. 11 years ago, I did something I wish I could forget forever. I was 12, and my father took me to the general store in town. I asked him if I could stay with our horse and buggy while he went inside to purchase supplies. Okay, but you stay out of trouble now, here. What I really wanted to do was look at a pistol he had kept hidden underneath the seat for emergencies. He never let me touch the gun, and that made me curious all the more. I made sure no one was watching me and took it out very carefully. It was a fine piece, a 38 military and police, the most famous revolver Smith and Wesson ever made. I wasn't thinking and squeezed the trigger, never thinking it could be loaded, but it was. The sound exploded down the street and echoed as if it came from all directions. The hot barrel burnt my fingers, so I dropped the gun on the floor.
Guest (Male): Hey!
Dwayne Oswald: Then I heard someone yell.
Guest (Male): It's Garrison, it's John Garrison.
Dwayne Oswald: I looked across the street, and there was a man lying there. I wondered what was wrong with him. Scared, I slipped the gun back under the seat and ran over to where the man was. By then, there was a crowd all around him. All I could see was this man's face. It was pale. Dr. Bowles, who had an office right there, he rushed to help him.
Jack Allen: Please, folks, I need some room here.
Dwayne Oswald: I heard the gun go off. I think it came from over there near the general store.
Chris: No, it didn't. It came from that direction. I swear on it.
Dwayne Oswald: We have to find the killer before he gets away.
Jack Allen: You two, go down Main Street. Rest of you cut across the park and spread out.
Guest (Male): Let's go.
Dwayne Oswald: The man on the street had been shot. Now men were searching for a killer. With growing horror, I realized they were looking for me. Come on, son. You best hop back in the buggy and wait there. I'm going to have a look around to see if I can find whoever did this. I wanted to say something. I wanted to confess, but I kept thinking they'd throw my daddy, maybe even my whole family, in jail for what I'd done. So I kept quiet while they searched for the killer. And later, when the newspapers said the bullet that killed the man in the street had come from a Smith and Wesson, I was sure my father would realize what had happened, but then I heard him tell my mother that it couldn't have been his gun because he'd unloaded it a couple of days before we went to town. He kept the bullets in a box further under the seat. I was relieved, but guilt-stricken all the same. It was one bullet, one bullet that he'd missed when he'd unloaded the gun. It was enough. The search for the mystery killer eventually ended. No one ever found out. The man who died was a father too. He had three daughters, 12, 7, and 3 years old. 11 years later, I fell in love with his oldest daughter, but I could not love her and live with this wretched secret. And so, I have broken our engagement. Now I must break these chains of guilt. Coward that I am, unable to confess, I am burying this box. You are reading this letter, and you may be surprised by what you found here. If these items lead you to me,
Jack Allen: then I will accept my fate and face my punishment. Until then, I have buried my sin.
Eugene Meltsner: What a tragedy.
Jack Allen: And to think his whole life.
Chris: Mr. Allen, there's one more thing in the box.
Jack Allen: Oh. Oh, it's wrapped up. Hand me that pocket knife, Wayne.
Dwayne Oswald: Here.
Jack Allen: Thank you. If I cut this twine. Good heavens.
Chris: That's the gun he used.
Dwayne Oswald: Whoa.
Eugene Meltsner: Quite startling.
Dwayne Oswald: So I guess this guy got off free after all.
Jack Allen: Has he? He may still be alive.
Eugene Meltsner: Uh, Mr. Allen, shouldn't we report this to the police?
Jack Allen: Yes, we should. Though I doubt the police will be interested in a murder case that took place back in the 20s. I tell you what, leave the box with me. I'll call a friend of mine at the police department to see what he thinks.
Eugene Meltsner: Uh, Mr. Allen, would it be permissible to make a copy of these documents?
Jack Allen: I suppose so. Copier's right over there. Help yourself.
Chris: Can I have a copy too, since we're partners, like you said?
Eugene Meltsner: Certainly, Jared.
Officer Murphy: Hello?
Jack Allen: Oh, Officer Murphy, Jack Allen here.
Officer Murphy: Yes, Jack.
Jack Allen: I've got something to talk to you about.
Eugene Meltsner: There's a new mystery in Odyssey. Jones and Parker are on the case. Your kids will love the new book, Jones and Parker Case Files: The Nemesis. 16 new mysteries to solve, full of fun and faith for ages 8 to 12. Go to adventuresinodyssey.com/jonesandparker.
Dwayne Oswald: I can't believe it. I'm at the library on my day off.
Chris: You never should have told me about these microfiche machines. They're amazing. They've got all the old newspapers right here to look at. Now you read the article to me, and I'll make the notes with my detective pencil.
Dwayne Oswald: Detective pencil?
Chris: Go, and stick to the facts.
Dwayne Oswald: Okay, let's see. John P. Garrison, husband and father of three, was fatally wounded on Main Street at approximately noon this past Wednesday.
Chris: All right, got it.
Dwayne Oswald: He was walking down the pavement when suddenly, blah, blah, blah, people search for the culprit. Dr. Bowles tried valiantly to save the man, yada, yada, yada, no suspects. Oh, and it says that Garrison leaves behind a loving wife and three daughters, Rachel, Grace, and Ruth.
Chris: Okay, so we've got the name of John P. Garrison and his family. That's a start.
Dwayne Oswald: Yeah, funny, because that name sounds familiar to me.
Chris: The murder was in 1921. He writes a secret note 11 years later. Using my detective calculator.
Eugene Meltsner: Detective calculator.
Chris: I can determine the exact year was
Dwayne Oswald: 1932.
Chris: Of course. That's the year our mystery man said he broke off his engagement to Mr. Garrison's oldest daughter, and her name is there at the end of the article.
Dwayne Oswald: It's Rachel, Rachel Garrison. Rachel Garrison.
Chris: Look, here, you see? They do engagement announcements in the newspaper. So, if our mystery man was engaged to Rachel Garrison, it'll be in here somewhere. And once we find it, voila, we find the name of our mystery man.
Dwayne Oswald: That would probably be in 1931 or 1932.
Chris: Keep looking.
Dwayne Oswald: All right, we we've got a sighting.
Chris: Great.
Dwayne Oswald: Rachel Garrison, daughter of Mrs. John P. Garrison, has announced her engagement to...
Chris: Thomas Newcastle. That's our mystery man.
Dwayne Oswald: This is perfect.
Chris: Next, we look him up in the phone book. They've got one right over here.
Dwayne Oswald: All right, go ahead and look him up. I want to keep scanning these pages. Wait a second, this can't be. Hey, hey, Jared.
Chris: Keep it down, will ya? I don't want to get thrown out again. Let's see. TB, TJ, Tammy, Terry, Thomas! Thomas Newcastle, I found him!
Dwayne Oswald: I can't believe this.
Chris: Thomas Newcastle lives at 615 Old Gate Road.
Dwayne Oswald: But it's all wrong.
Chris: What's wrong?
Dwayne Oswald: Look at this article. Rachel Garrison, daughter of Mrs. John P. Garrison, has announced her engagement to Charles Oswald.
Chris: Okay, so Rachel got engaged again, so what?
Dwayne Oswald: Look at the name.
Chris: Oswald. Yeah, that's your last name too. Wait a second. Hey, are you?
Dwayne Oswald: Rachel Oswald is my great-grandmother.
Chris: Wait a minute. Then that means that...
Dwayne Oswald: Yeah, Thomas New Castle murdered my great-great-grandfather.
Jack Allen: Eugene? Eugene?
Eugene Meltsner: Oh, hello, Mr. Allen.
Jack Allen: I'm on my way back from the police station. They asked me to drop off your buried treasure.
Eugene Meltsner: Oh, they were that interested?
Jack Allen: More than that, Eugene. The police have decided to reopen the case.
Eugene Meltsner: After all these years?
Jack Allen: Well, there's no statute of limitations for murder.
Chris: Of course.
Jack Allen: The police want us to stay tight-lipped about your find while they conduct their investigation.
Eugene Meltsner: Hmm.
Jack Allen: We should tell Jared and Dwayne. Are they here?
Eugene Meltsner: Oh, I haven't seen them since we left your shop earlier. Oh my.
Jack Allen: What's wrong?
Eugene Meltsner: I made them copies of the documents from the box.
Jack Allen: Why did they want copies?
Eugene Meltsner: Curiosity, I thought, but, uh...
Jack Allen: You, you don't think they'd try to solve this case on their own, do you?
Eugene Meltsner: Two boys, one with hyper imagination.
Jack Allen: Eugene, we have to find those boys. If the man they're looking for is still alive and they find him, who knows what he'll do to them.
Chris: This is incredible, Dwayne. Thomas Newcastle actually murdered your great-great-grandfather, and we found him.
Dwayne Oswald: It all makes sense now. When we visited my Aunt Thelma as a kid, I remember hearing about some sort of a tragedy in our family history, but I never got the whole story because they said I was too young. There was a shooting and something else. What was it? A letter.
Chris: What letter? The one in the box?
Dwayne Oswald: No, no, they called it the Dear Thomas letter. Quick, let's go to my house.
Chris: Ah, nothing like the smell of an old attic.
Dwayne Oswald: All right, the letters in a jewelry box. I remember now because I found it when I was playing up here once.
Chris: Does it have any?
Dwayne Oswald: There it is, right there between the moose head and the cello. See it?
Chris: Yeah. All right, I'll get it. Got it. There we go.
Dwayne Oswald: Okay, this is it. My great grandma wrote this right before she died. The whole family still talks about it.
Chris: So, what's it say?
Dwayne Oswald: Dear Thomas, I've reached the end of my life, and though it has been a good life, I think of you still.
Jared DeWhite: Still, I'm haunted by what happened between us. I often wonder why you broke off our engagement that summer so long, long ago. I knew then that something was terribly wrong. You seemed so burdened by hurts that you would not share, troubled by a pain you would not speak of. And whether you meant to or not, you passed that hurt and pain to me when you abruptly ended our engagement. I have spent these years angry and confused when I thought of it, but now, even so late in my life, I have finally found peace. You may laugh, Thomas, when I tell you why, for you and I considered ourselves above church-going. Yet, I have joined their ranks. I met the one they speak of, Jesus Christ, and to my amazement, he washed all my hurt away, Thomas. So I think of you now. I think of that burden, that pain, and I wonder if you still have it, because if you do,
Dwayne Oswald: Jesus is standing close by right now to take your burden, to forgive you, to help you forgive, to heal you, Thomas, as he did for me. On the day you left me, you asked me to forgive you. I couldn't, but today I can. Thomas, I forgive you. With love, Rachel. P.S. I often wonder if you still have that fedora I gave you.
Chris: Wow, and he never saw this letter.
Dwayne Oswald: Nobody knew who the mysterious Thomas was.
Chris: But Dwayne, you know who he is.
Dwayne Oswald: Yeah, I guess I do.
Chris: Let's take it to him.
Dwayne Oswald: What? We can't.
Chris: We have to.
Dwayne Oswald: Why? He murdered my great-great-grandfather.
Chris: And he broke your great-grandmother's heart too. But didn't you see what she was saying? She wrote this letter to tell him about forgiveness and peace, and it's like a message of hope from beyond the grave. Maybe this guy's been torturing himself all these years for a stupid accident that happened when he was our age. This letter could make all the difference in the world to him. Don't you see? It's like a mission from God.
Dwayne Oswald: Want to contact us about the episodes you're hearing? Visit our website at adventuresinodyssey.com or talk to someone at Focus on the Family. Call 1-800-A-FAMILY, with a parent's permission, of course. We always love hearing from you.
Chris: Weird. I didn't realize Old Gate Road was a hospital.
Dwayne Oswald: Retirement home. What room did the nurse say?
Chris: 2B. And did you notice that she called him Doctor Newcastle?
Dwayne Oswald: Jared, I'm having second thoughts about all this.
Chris: It's too late. We're here. Doctor Thomas K. Newcastle. The moment of truth.
Guest (Male): Hello? Who's there?
Chris: Uh, visitors.
Guest (Male): Visitors? Come on in. The door's unlocked.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Hello there. Who do we have here? It looks like two fine young men. You all have names, don't you?
Chris: Oh, right. I'm Jared.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: And your name?
Chris: Uh, his name is Dwayne.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: I see. Well, my name's Doctor Thomas Newcastle, but you can just call me Doc for short. Come in, come in. You all from a youth group or something?
Chris: No, not really.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Then what can I do for you?
Chris: Dwayne has something to give you, don't you, Dwayne?
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Oh?
Dwayne Oswald: Uh, it's a letter addressed to you from my great-grandmother, Rachel Oswald.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Rachel Oswald? Well, if that doesn't beat all... Where is she? How is she?
Dwayne Oswald: Mm, she died, just last year.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: I see. That's a problem getting to be my age. You lose everybody you once knew.
Dwayne Oswald: Once, long time ago.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: That's right. In fact, believe it or not, I was engaged to her.
Dwayne Oswald: I know.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Do you? Did she tell you about me?
Dwayne Oswald: No. No one ever knew who Thomas was.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Then how did you know?
Dwayne Oswald: We found your box.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Box? What box?
Dwayne Oswald: The one you buried behind what's now Whits End.
Chris: Dwayne.
Dwayne Oswald: It had a hat in it and a newspaper article and a letter.
Chris: Dwayne.
Dwayne Oswald: And the gun you used to shoot my great-great-grandfather.
Chris: Oh boy.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Oh, that box.
Dwayne Oswald: You're not going to deny it?
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: No, son, I won't. I've wondered for years whether or not that box would ever catch up with me, and now it has. Not that I ever spent a day without thinking about it. Listen to me, Dwayne. I can guess what you're thinking. You're thinking that I'm a murderer, and you're right, I am. You see, when I was no older than you, I made a terrible mistake. And what's worse, I didn't have the courage to confess it. So my whole life has been spent trying to live, trying to carry on, trying to cope while a box buried with my crime lay waiting for this day. And now, the only thing I can think to say is I'm so sorry for what I did. I won't ask for your forgiveness because that's impossible to get, but I'm sorry anyway.
Chris: Wayne.
Dwayne Oswald: I think you should read the letter, Dr. Newcastle.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: The letter?
Dwayne Oswald: If you want forgiveness, it'll tell you where to look.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: All right, son, I'll read it, if not for my sake, but for the memory of dear Rachel. Who's there?
Jack Allen: Dr. Thomas Newcastle, this is the police.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Hi, Mr. Allen. Hello, Eugene.
Chris: Hi, Jared.
Eugene Meltsner: Greetings, Dwayne and Jared. You've arrived just in time.
Dwayne Oswald: Connie said you wanted us to come back here.
Jack Allen: That's right. We have a little ceremony we wanted to perform.
Chris: Ceremony?
Jack Allen: Mm-hmm. I suppose you saw the newspapers. Dr. Newcastle confessed to everything.
Dwayne Oswald: I saw.
Chris: They said the judge is going to put him on some kind of probation because of how young he was when it happened and how old he is now.
Eugene Meltsner: Indeed, a merciful thing for the judge to do.
Dwayne Oswald: But what's that got to do with this hole where the box was found? To be honest, I don't even want to think about it.
Jack Allen: I understand, but you see, what the newspapers didn't say is that I went to visit Dr. Newcastle after he was arrested. I've spent quite a lot of time with him over the past few days.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Why?
Jack Allen: Well, I thought he might need a friend. He told me about your visit. He also told me about your great-grandmother's letter to him.
Dwayne Oswald: What about it?
Jack Allen: Well, that letter persuaded Dr. Newcastle he could be forgiven for what he did and had tried to bury. But you already knew the letter would do that, didn't you, Dwayne?
Dwayne Oswald: Maybe.
Jack Allen: Maybe? As a result, Dr. Newcastle prayed to become a Christian.
Dr. Thomas Newcastle: Really?
Jack Allen: Mm-hmm. Now he wants to do something to symbolize his new life. That's why we're here, back at the hole you dug.
Chris: We're gonna bury something again?
Dwayne Oswald: But... what?
Jack Allen: The same box, only now it's open and it's empty. The contents have been revealed. Dr. Newcastle is free.
Eugene Meltsner: At least in the spiritual sense.
Jack Allen: So, you see, the three of you played an important part in bringing a man to God, which is why I wanted you to be here when we buried it again. Go ahead, Eugene.
Eugene Meltsner: Of course. I suppose the honor of burying it should go to the one who dug it up in the first place, Jared.
Jared DeWhite: Me? Why do I always get stuck doing the dirty work?
Eugene Meltsner: Perhaps because you're so good at it. You know, it seems as if we should say something.
Jack Allen: Yeah, a couple of things come to mind.
Eugene Meltsner: Then please.
Jack Allen: The Bible tells us that the Lord is compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in love. He will not always accuse, nor will he harbor his anger forever. He does not treat us as our sins deserve or repay us according to our iniquities. So, though we run and hide our sins, God still seeks us out and through his son forgives us. Let's hope we all learn from Dr. Newcastle's lesson. Amen. Amen.
Jared DeWhite: It sure is sad that Dr. Newcastle spent his whole life feeling guilty about something that he could have been forgiven of a long time ago. But I'm glad he finally found Jesus and gave that sin over to him to be cleansed. Have you ever tried to hide something bad that you've done? Like the gang from Odyssey learned today, you probably discovered that it doesn't work too well, because even if you hide it from others, God still knows, and so do you. But like the verse Jack quoted said, God does not treat us as our sin deserves. He forgives us. We just need to confess our sins to him, accept his forgiveness, and then try to do better next time. Just like Dr. Newcastle, Duane, and Jared, you'll find the real treasure doesn't come in a buried box. It comes in uncovering the sin in your heart and realizing the amazing love of Jesus. If you'd ever like to write to us, we'd love to hear from you. Just drop us a note at Adventures in Odyssey, Colorado Springs, Colorado, 80995. In Canada, write to Box 9800, Vancouver, BC, V6B 4G3. And when you do, ask about how you can get your own copy of today's episode. It's called Buried Sin. Adventures in Odyssey is a presentation of Focus on the Family. Buried Sin was written by John Beebe and directed by Bill Myers. Our production engineer was Jonathan Crow. And I'm Chris, hoping you'll join us again next time for more Adventures in Odyssey.

Related Episodes

The Devil Made Me Do It

Tuesday, November 17

A Lesson From Mike

Monday, November 16

B-TV: Forgiveness

Saturday, November 14

About Adventures in Odyssey

Part Saturday morning cartoon…part radio drama…and all designed to help your family grow in faith! Adventures in Odyssey combines the characters kids love with the faith lessons parents appreciate. Produced by Focus on the Family.

About Focus on the Family

Focus on the Family is a global Christian ministry dedicated to helping families thrive. We provide help and resources for couples to build healthy marriages that reflect God’s design, and for parents to raise their children according to morals and values grounded in biblical principles.

We’re here to come alongside families with relevance and grace at each stage of their journey. We support families as they seek to teach their children about God and His beautiful design for the family, protect themselves from the harmful influences of culture and equip themselves to make a greater difference in the lives of those around them.

No matter who you are, what you’re going through or what challenges your family may be facing, we’re here to help. With practical resources — like our 1-800 Family Help line, counseling and websites — we’re committed to providing trustworthy, biblical guidance and support.

Contact Adventures in Odyssey with Focus on the Family

Mailing Address
Focus on the Family
8605 Explorer Dr.
Colorado Springs, CO
80920-1051

Toll-free Number
(800) A-FAMILY (232-6459)

Sponsored Links

Devotionals

View All